| |
My Christmas Tradition
58 |
|
| 12.14.08 |
Every year I try to watch as many versions of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol as possible. The ghosts of Christmas Past, Present and Future, Bob Cratchit and Tiny Tim ... the highs, the lows, the happy ending ... Dickens, you're a wonder! So far this year I have seen the Reginald Owen version (1938, masterfully edited), the George C. Scott version (1984, he's not even "doing" an accent, but he has such fantastic diction he just sounds British), the Patrick Stewart version (my favorite, kind of gruesome) and the Vanessa Williams version (she plays Ebony Scrooge - it's a mutant spawn of Dickens and Dreamgirls).
If I wanted to, I could probably do nothing but watch A Christmas Carol from Thanksgiving until December 25. So fertile is this classic storyline of sin and redemption. I could watch A Bugs Bunny Christmas Carol, in which Porky Pig plays Bob Cratchit -- inspired casting! A Carol Christmas, starring Tori Spelling, William Shatner and Gary Coleman. Don't ask. The Jetson's Christmas Carol, the Flintstone's Christmas Carol, not to mention the All Dogs Christmas Carol.
But perhaps the worst version -- and therefore also the best -- is The Miracle at Christmas: Ebbie's Story starring Susan Lucci, aka Erica Kane of All My Children. I believe that Dickens had a sense of humor and that he wrote with a keen sense of marketability (long before the term was coined). But even Dickens -- despite his tolerance of human foibles -- might have rolled his eyes at this one. Bless her heart, Lucci is not exactly known for the subtlety of her acting. And if this edition were played as straightforward camp, her scenery chewing would be amusing. But the juxtaposition of biting social commentary and and highly glossed lip biting ... well, it's one for the record books.
Oh well, even if an occasional adaptation disappoints, I can always reconnect to this classic storyline through the timeless work of Alec Guiness or Scrooge McDuck. |
|
| |
Num
of Responses: 0 |
|
| |
|
|